Teaching Kids to Invest: A First Stock Account Without the Hype

1 month ago

By admin

Start with a hypothetical 12-year-old. She has $600 from birthdays and pet-sitting, and her parents agree to add $25 a month if she adds $25 of her own. That’s $50 a month going into a broad stock index fund. If the fund earned a hypothetical 6% a year on average, by the time she turns 22 she would have put in $6,000 and the account would be worth roughly $8,200, plus whatever the original $600 grew to. Not life-changing money. But at 22 she would also have watched an account go up and down for ten years, and that experience is the real payoff.

Now add one more piece to the example. In year three, the market drops and her balance falls from $2,400 to $1,900. That’s the month the lesson either sticks or falls apart. Parents who plan for that moment in advance tend to raise kids who keep investing. Parents who sold the idea as “watch your money grow” have some explaining to do.

Picking the right kind of account

A minor can’t open a brokerage account alone. You have three realistic options for a 10- to 16-year-old:

Most families with a 10- to 14-year-old start with a custodial brokerage account. Once a teen gets a first job, a custodial Roth IRA is worth adding.

Taxes are usually small at this scale, but large custodial accounts can trigger the kiddie tax, which taxes some of a child’s investment income at the parents’ rate. See our kiddie tax explainer if the account starts producing real dividends or gains.

Letting the child pick, inside guardrails

Kids learn more from a choice they made than from one made for them. The trick is to offer a short menu instead of the whole market.

A starter menu

All three are low-cost and diversified. Ask your child to look up each one’s holdings, fees and history and explain to you which they prefer and why. A 10-year-old can handle “this one owns about 500 big American companies.” A 15-year-old can compare expense ratios and figure out how much a 0.5% fee would cost over 20 years.

What about single stocks?

Many kids want to buy shares of a company they know: a game maker, a sneaker brand, a streaming service. Some parents allow a small slice, say 10% of the account, for individual stocks. That works as a side experiment, as long as the core stays in a fund. Comparing the single stock to the index fund after a year or two is often more convincing than any lecture.

Keep the account away from options, leverage, crypto trading apps and anything marketed with countdown timers or prize animations. If a platform makes buying feel like a game, it isn’t the right place for a first account.

Talking about losses before they happen

Have the conversation on a calm day, not during a sell-off. A few points work well at these ages:

When a drop arrives, sit down together and look at the share count, not just the dollar balance. Then ask: has anything changed about why we picked this fund? Usually the answer is no.

Showing what time does

The compound interest calculator on Investor.gov is a good teaching tool. Have your child enter $50 a month for 10 years, then for 40 years, at the same hypothetical return. Seeing the 40-year number next to the 10-year number tends to land harder than any speech about patience. Then try the same 40 years starting at age 25 instead of 15 and compare.

Routines that keep it going

If you’re also teaching credit, our guide to teaching kids about credit age by age pairs well with this one. Investing shows money growing over time; credit shows what borrowing costs.

A simple next step

This week, ask your child one question: “If you had $100 to put away for ten years, where would you put it?” Listen to the answer without correcting it. Then show them the three-fund menu, open a custodial account together, and let them make the first purchase themselves. Set up the monthly contribution before you log off, so the routine starts on its own.

About the Author

Author

Trending Articles: