Mortgage Escrow: Why Your Payment Changes Every Year

4 weeks ago

By admin

Take a hypothetical family with a fixed-rate mortgage. Their principal and interest are $1,600 a month and will stay $1,600 until the loan is paid off. On top of that, the servicer collects for property taxes and homeowners insurance through escrow. Last year those two bills totaled $6,000, so escrow added $500 a month, for a total payment of $2,100.

This year the county reassessed the home and the tax bill rose by $600. The insurance renewal came in $1,200 higher. The servicer paid both bills on time, but it had only collected for the old amounts, so the account ran $1,800 short.

When the annual escrow analysis arrives, two things happen at once. The new monthly escrow amount becomes $7,800 divided by 12, or $650. And the $1,800 shortage has to be made up, either in a lump sum or spread over the next 12 months at $150 a month. The family’s payment jumps from $2,100 to $2,400, even though their mortgage rate never moved. That’s the whole mechanism, and it surprises people every year.

Checklist: reading your escrow statement

What escrow actually is

An escrow account is a holding account your mortgage servicer runs. Each month a slice of your payment goes into it, and when the property tax bill or insurance premium comes due, the servicer pays it from the account. Lenders like this arrangement because unpaid taxes can lead to a tax lien that outranks the mortgage, and a lapse in insurance leaves their collateral unprotected.

Escrow is required on many loans, including most government-backed mortgages and conventional loans with smaller down payments. Some borrowers with more equity can waive it, sometimes for a fee or a slightly higher rate.

Why the annual analysis exists

Under the federal rules that govern escrow, known as Regulation X under the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, servicers generally have to review the account once a year, project the next 12 months of bills and send you a statement. The CFPB’s explainer on escrow accounts covers the basics.

The rules also limit how much extra the servicer can hold. The cushion is capped at one-sixth of the estimated annual disbursements, roughly two months’ worth. If your statement shows a cushion larger than that, ask why.

Shortage, deficiency and surplus are different things

These three words show up on escrow statements and mean different things.

Shortage

The projected balance at its lowest point next year would fall below the allowed cushion. This is what happened to the family in the example. Federal rules give servicers a few ways to handle it depending on the size; for a shortage of a month’s escrow payment or more, the servicer generally has to let you spread repayment over at least 12 months, though you can usually pay it in one lump sum if you prefer.

Deficiency

The account actually went negative because the servicer advanced money to pay a bill. The repayment options are similar but can be tighter.

Surplus

The account collected more than it needed. If the surplus is $50 or more and you’re current on the loan, the servicer generally must refund it within 30 days of the analysis. Smaller amounts can be credited toward next year.

Paying the shortage now or later

Spreading the shortage over 12 months keeps cash in your pocket but makes this year’s payment higher than next year’s will be, assuming bills hold steady. Paying it in a lump sum lowers the monthly payment right away to just the new escrow amount.

In the example, paying $1,800 up front drops the payment from $2,400 to $2,250. There’s no interest on an escrow shortage either way, so the choice is about cash flow. If the family’s emergency fund is thin, spreading it out is usually the safer move.

The two bills behind most increases

Property taxes

Tax increases come from reassessments, rate changes approved by local governments, or the loss of an exemption. A common one is buying a home where the previous owner had a homestead or senior exemption. The first year’s escrow was set using the old, lower bill, and the next year’s bill reflects your actual taxes. Make sure you’ve filed for any homestead exemption you qualify for; many counties require you to apply.

If you believe the assessed value is too high, most counties have an appeal window. It’s often short and starts when the assessment notice is mailed, not when the tax bill arrives.

Homeowners insurance

Premiums have climbed sharply in many parts of the country in recent years, especially in areas exposed to storms, wildfire and hail. You can shop the policy at renewal, raise the deductible, or ask about discounts for a new roof or monitored alarms. Just make sure any new policy meets your lender’s coverage requirements, and send the new declarations page to the servicer so it pays the right company.

When the servicer gets it wrong

Servicers make mistakes: paying the wrong county, paying a canceled insurance policy, missing an exemption, or double-counting a bill. If something on the statement doesn’t match your records, you can send a written notice of error. Federal rules require the servicer to acknowledge and investigate it within set timeframes. Keep copies of your tax bills and insurance declarations so you can back up the claim.

If you’re about to refinance or move, our guide to applying for a mortgage with one spouse or both covers what changes on a new loan.

If you only remember one thing

A fixed rate fixes principal and interest, not your payment. Taxes and insurance flow straight through escrow, so check your county assessment and insurance renewal each year, and you’ll see the next escrow change coming months before the statement does.

Frequently asked questions

Can I cancel escrow and pay taxes and insurance myself?

Sometimes. Conventional loans often allow it once you have enough equity and a clean payment history. Government-backed loans generally don’t. Ask the servicer for its waiver requirements and whether a fee applies.

Why did my payment change in the middle of the year?

Servicers can run an extra analysis when something significant changes, such as a new insurance policy or a supplemental tax bill. You should receive a statement explaining the new amount.

Does a bigger escrow payment hurt my credit?

No. Escrow isn’t reported separately. What matters is paying the full new amount; paying the old amount can leave you short and eventually delinquent.

What happens to escrow when I sell or refinance?

The old loan is paid off and the servicer refunds the remaining escrow balance, usually within a few weeks. A new loan starts its own escrow account at closing.

About the Author

Author

Trending Articles: